A major economic and brand problem is the turnover of both poor and high performers. When poor performers are terminated, it not only costs time and resources to replace the individual, but it can also negatively impact a company’s brand and its ability to attract potential candidates to other career openings. Nobody likes to join a company where people fail, and anyone who is terminated is likely to inform their network about the negative experience.
Losing a top performer is the most expensive problem. It not only negatively influences the top line (especially in sales), but also increases replacement expenses and the ramp-up costs required to bring a new candidate up to performance standards. Most companies track retention and turnover, but few collect the data needed to understand turnover and fix the problem.
There are three potential data points that can help organizations understand current retention issues, provide insights into fixing problems, and, equally important, continue to reinforce what is working well. The three data points are: WHO, WHEN, and WHY.
- WHO – What are the characteristics of individuals who stay versus those who leave? It is essential to have a control group to determine the differences between the two groups. Many companies only collect data on those who leave and assume that those who stay are different. In every study, there are similarities between those who leave and those who stay. The key is to identify the differences. This is a very simple benchmark study. The study can be expanded to determine not only who stays and who leaves, but also the differences between voluntary and involuntary terminations, and high performers versus low performers.
- WHEN – At what point do individuals leave? Early turnover in the first three months typically indicates a selection problem. It is usually a mismatch between the requirements of the position and the expectations of both the company and the individual. Early voluntary turnover is often the result of expectations established during the recruitment process. Turnover between three and six months is often a training and onboarding problem. Longer-term turnover, after six months, is more often related to fit with the coach, the team, and the culture. The “when” can also be included in the benchmark study.
- WHY – Why do individuals stay or leave? The reasons individuals stay and leave can be assessed through ongoing Stay and Leave interviews. These provide continuous data to track changes that may occur in the marketplace or within the corporate culture.
Understanding Long-Term Effective Retention – When and why reflect longer-term issues and allow organizations to better understand long-term effective retention and rolling retention rates. Effective retention means keeping high performers and is often very different from simply retaining employees at all levels of performance. Tracking rolling retention rates also provides more in-depth insights into fixing longer-term turnover.
An example is comparing four-year rolling retention with one-year retention. One-year retention tracks overall retention for the current or previous year, whereas four-year rolling retention looks at retention longitudinally. For example, one-year retention might be 50%, while four-year retention might be approximately 6% (i.e., 50% × 50% × 50% × 50%), assuming the same annual retention rate.
In other words, if you hire 100 people today, how many will still be with you in four years? Moving from Data to Intelligence to Strategy.
The strategy is simple: Fix what is not working well and continue to leverage and expand what is working well.
Through our 47 years of data collection on all aspects of retention, we help companies design studies and collect data that provide the intelligence and insights needed to target and maximize retention and fix turnover problems.